Wednesday, 6 August 2014

Working with Indian MBA Students from IIM Calcutta - The Power of Integration


So, this Tuesday I got to spend the afternoon with 23 MBA students from the Indian Institute of Management Calcutta ...

What an interesting session we had :-)

I loved their energy and inquiring, open, spirit. They threw themselves into the session - and we explored some of the unorthodox creative edges of strategic thinking together.

To the music of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan Massive Attack Remix, we did a "line up" of who they admired most and might emulate: at one end of the line Vinoba Bhave and Rabindranath Tagor, and at the other end of the line Mukesh Ambani, richest man in India. What do you think happened? Where on the continuum did the students stand?

This led to a fascinating discussion about the role of unorthodox ideas in refreshing strategic thinking. The fusion of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and Massive Attack, the integration of perspectives from entrepreneurship and spirituality ... Each of these are powerful because they challenge a deeply held and rigid framing. Our orthodox conception of "strategy" is too small, and by playing with the framing we can open  our eyes and ears to more richness.

We looked at the importance of "exploring" in strategic thinking, and at the many ways in which strategic exploration can start.

We took a look into "artful knowing" (using more than just words and logic, we drew images of strategy and saw the unstated metaphors we all hold come to life in the room). A huge amount of energy was unleashed as the students made and remade "clusters " of the images, seeing the many different and previously unstated perspectives on strategy held even within an MBA group from IIMC.

We looked at different psychological impacts on strategic thinking - from linguistic framing to deeply held world views - and we saw many ways of making these more obvious, less hidden .... and by challenging and shifting them we made new options, new ways of seeing, become more possible.

I left the room feeling we had done some really interesting work together - and sad only that we didn't have another day to explore together. At the heart of our work was the place of richer and diverse ways of seeing, and of the creative energy and potential that comes from bringing together views, perspectives, models of seeing or action, and allowing them to emerge into new forms, just like Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and Massive Attack .... together they change the frame and something different and special emerges.

I was left wondering whether maybe it will be India that brings us a new way of seeing sustainable business, from a genuine fusion of big business and deep spirit, the fusion of  Bhave and Tagore with the entrepreneurial energy of these MBA students.

Anything is possible when people, openness and energy come together.






Tuesday, 5 August 2014

When is enough just taking the piss?


So today I was working with a great group of MBA students from the Indian Institute of Management, Calcutta ...

The Economist had this really interesting piece about Mukesh Ambani, who heads the largest privately held company in India, Reliance Industries (See Mukesh Ambani) ...India's richest man, and some say the most powerful too.

Among other notable statistics, this one struck me as very interesting: Mr Ambani has built himself the most expensive private home on the planet (apparently - though who knows?) .... 

But let's put it this way, it's pretty hard to miss because it's a 27-story sky-scraper tower in Mumbai :-) .... He's not, as it were, hiding away on a private island with this one. 

Have a look:



It's stirred up a bit of comment, mostly from the "Billionaire Homes Top !0 Lists" ...yes, this exists :-) ...
But also from people you might not expect ... Tata's Ratan Tata was quoted as saying that this was the kind of behaviour that starts revolutions, but latter denied the statement ...Tata Comment Denied

But it did make me wonder: why do you need a 27-story skyscraper home? And in a country where the 2009-2013 per capita GDP is less than $1500 is it the right gesture? World Bank per cap data,  

As someone in a movie once said:

Bud Fox: How much is enough? 
Gordon Gekko: It's not a question of enough, pal. It's a zero sum game, somebody wins, somebody loses. Money itself isn't lost or made, it's simply transferred from one perception to another

Quite. 

So long as you don't worry about your social license to operate, long term, that is.

Sunday, 3 August 2014

Bankers, Business and the Oath ...Why Something Much More Will Be Needed


Apparently it's time for bankers to take the Hippocatic Oath - you know, the one doctors take.

You can find the proposal discussed in the Guardian, Banking Oath ... And in more detail at ResPublica Document. I think this is an important and worthwhile contribution to thinking on a very important topic.

But then, why stop at bankers? Why not ask everyone in business to do the same? Banking isn't unique? And what would happen if directors of, say tobacco companies, refined sugar producers, or bomb makers had to swear an oath "to do no harm"?

Of course there is one massive difference between bankers, businesses and medics .... Your doctor has to be qualified to do the job ...

Now I know that Graucho said something like "what do you call the guy who passes out bottom of his class at medical school? .... Doctor" ....  But the truth is Doctors do have to be qualified and they are firmly members of a professional community.

It is just not the same in banking and business.

I have heard, seen and read so, so many business leaders disparaging business education - preferring the school of life and all that: "those who can do, those who can't teach" and so on ....

You never hear this from Doctors .... They never say, "forget all that crap from four centuries of studying human anatomy, physiology, pathology, pharmacology, virology ... forget all of those dull and boring 'ologies ... just give me a scalpel and let me in there ..."  You just never, never hear it ....

But in business, it is respectable to be disparage learning, respectable to wing it, respectable to be utterly unqualified and part of no professional community whatsoever ...

Now (and Sumantra Ghoshal nailed this quite brilliantly in my view: see Bad Management Theories) Business Schools bear lots of the blame for this, but not all of it. The way we in our society respect ignorance in business and even glorify it is also part of the problem ...

We need a better community of practice around just what organisational leadership and business leadership is. Oaths "to do no harm" would be pointless without the ability to see and understand the harm we may be doing.

Harm in business, banking or not, isn't just a matter of harm to this one patient, it would have to be more systemic, or we can be "ethical" and still go to hell in the proverbial handcart ...

I am all for business being ethical, trusted and professional. Let's start by recognizing it isn't just bankers that are struggling for credibility here

Reflections On the Centenary of World War One



(image created by Chris Nichols from mash-up of web images)



As we approach the eve of the centenary, we recall that one hundred years ago today Britain, at least, was not yet at war.

Within 48 hours of now, 100 years ago, Lord Grey may well have said those famous words, "the lamps are going out all over Europe, we shall not see them lit again in our life time" ....

And how easily war seems to come and come again.

Each time it comes, it brings moments of the most astonishing personal bravery
Each time it comes it calls up the spirit of nations together, of burdens shared, of courage, of stoicism

And each time it comes, it comes again, as certain as the tide

For all of our history, our experience, our supposed intelligence as a species, we seem incapable of spotting the incoming tide of war and we remain as unable, or unwilling, as ever to turn away from it.

As we approach this centenary let us by all means remember the fallen

But let us remember too that hard though war is, the harder struggle seems to be avoiding conflict with skill

Our ability to meet with difference and to create solutions without bloodshed, our ability to meet where meeting seems impossible, this seems to me to be the necessary frontier for our training, intelligence and efforts

If this centenary teaches us something let it teach us that war, though it may sometimes feel just, is rarely if ever right








Saturday, 2 August 2014

What Barbara Hepworth's "Trio" Might Teach Us ...


I was at RAMM today in Exeter ... I went to have a mull at Detached and Timeless - contemporary artists inspired by nature and the spirit of place ....

But while there my eye was caught by Barbara Hepworth's 1948 painting Trio - a scene painted after the artist was allowed to observe surgery at the Princess Elizabeth Hospital, Exeter, in November 1947. I've snipped in an extract below ...






In the gallery notes Hepworth speaks that she had expected to find the experience difficult, unpleasant, but that it had been quite different to that. Recalling sketching in a sterilized notebook, she said:

"I was consistently absorbed by two things:  First, the extraordinary beauty of purpose and coordination between human beings all dedicated to the saving of life and the way that unity of purpose dictated a perfection of concentration, movement and gesture, and secondly, by the way this special grace (grace of mind and body) induced a spontaneous space composition, an articulated and animated kind of abstract sculpture..."

Isn't that beautiful?

Let's take it slowly ........ and let's set it beside what Jo Confino, David Grayling and I were edging around on Twitter earlier in response to Jo's Guardian piece on sustainability professionals (see Sustainability Professionals)

The Barbara Hepworth phrase "the extraordinary beauty of purpose and coordination between human beings all dedicated to the saving of life" speaks massively about the difference between what she saw in that operating room and what happens in boardroom conversations, whether about sustainability or about anything else ... What if, just what if, our radical, innovative new leaders do help organisations to re-frame so that there is such an "extraordinary beauty of purpose and coordination" and that there is a dedication towards activity that supports life? Just imagine how radical that would be ...

When she writes of "this special grace (grace of mind and body) induced a spontaneous space composition, an articulated and animated kind of abstract sculpture" ... I see in that an echo of what occasionally, just occasionally, happens in strategic conversations when purpose, intent and practice flow beautifully together in service of something bigger than business as usual, something that has the seeds in it of creating a new way of framing, a new way of working with this living world ... Where the form of the conversation becomes something more real, connected, flowing, deeper, wilder ....

We are not even close to this being normal in business. But Hepworth's observation reminds us that humans are capable of live giving, life saving, life serving collaboration, and that when we see it, we stand in wonder ...


Is Professional Sustainability Too Tame To Work?


Have you seen Jo Confino's fine and thoughtful piece in The Guardian Sustainable Business Blog, commenting on the launch of the Institute for Corporate Sustainability and Responsibility? You can get to Jo's article here

http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/blog/institute-corporate-responsibility-icrs-sustainability-professionals

Jo wonders ...When sustainability becomes a professional body accepted into the boardroom, have all the teeth dropped out? It's a good question.

I have a bias here. I co-direct the Ashridge MSc in Sustainability and Responsibility and potentially many of our graduates are involved in exactly the kind of roles Jo is concerned about, and might well be members of ICRS  https://icrs.info/ ...

One of the reasons I keep working is that I hope it is possible to change the nature of conversations with the largest organisations, so that genuine and more deeply framed explorations of what it means to be a sustainable and responsible organisation really do reach the top table. For this to happen we need skilled practitioners who can work inside organisations to change the very framing of business. It's a big ask, but its an even bigger ask to wait for the glorious revolution to put corporations against the proverbial wall. By the time that day comes, well .....

I spend a lot of my life inside massive organisations trying to change the nature of conversation, and it is always hard. We are a long way from anything that might be called sustainable business. Much of what passes for corporate sustainability is nothing like up to the job. Often you're banging your head against the very wall you once planned to put the bastards up against ... All of this is true ...

And yet there is a shift, over the past ten years I have see some strategy conversations beginning to address real-earth issues such as peak resource, earth justice and so on. And many more at least moving to bring consideration of sustainability into strategy and leadership conversations slightly further along the curve from mere compliance towards something deeper ....

There's a long long way to go and the work is hardly begun. And we need radical thinking inside organisations, skilled in challenging the frame and in sparking innovation AND skilled in doing so in language and approaches that can be heard and can help move and shape the organisational agenda ....




Is "sustainable responsible tobacco" a lie or a strategic possibility?


British American Tobacco not long ago published Value Shared: A Tobacco Company for the 21st Century (see the full report here: Value Shared: Sustainability at BAT ).

 BAT nails its colours pretty firmly to the mast of sustainability, saying “we have sharpened our business strategy, putting a much greater emphasis on sustainability… Our three key areas … Harm reduction, sustainable agriculture and corporate behaviour”.

Now it’s very easy to be cynical about this …. What on earth might be a truly sustainable and responsible tobacco company? 

After all the recent US Surgeon General’s report on 50 years of evidence didn’t leave much wiggle room ( USSurgeon General Report Exec Summary ). So much so that the US Department of Health aspires to eradicate tobacco smoking within a generation.

But this does raise some more interesting issues doesn’t it? 

After all, is tobacco that much more objectionable than, say, some fast food offers or sugar laden processed food production? Or for that matter, is selling tobacco less responsible than missile making, palm oil production, logging? And what is so noble about oil majors, sugary drinks and industrial agriculture? 

One way or another, as consumers, investors, pension holders, most of us are tied up in here somehow ….

The fact is we are all part of a complex and inter-connected system and none of us in business are acting in a way that is genuinely sustainable yet.

There is a lot of exploring, learning and creating to do before we can claim to have created business that genuinely does more good than harm to us, to life, to the future.

So long as there is more to corporate efforts than mere greenwash so long as somewhere in there is a genuine sense of inquiry into responsibility, so long as there is learning, experimentation and a will to learn, then there is hope